Based upon what you've said it looks like you may receive an On-the-Record decision, and since the file is back at ODAR you probably should be hearing something soon. If the paper does not meet the criteria for publication under the category it is submitted, it should be Rejected. If needed, you can still make changes to your report after it has been submitted, up until the Interactive Review Forum is activated by the associate editor. Editorial and Journal Policies - PNAS If you are waiting considerably longer to receive a decision from the Editor than the average review speed indicates, you can contact the Editor. Question on PNAS review system : academia Peer Review Process Overview - Ecological Society of America SCOTUSblog - Independent News & Analysis on the U.S. Supreme Court Placing your cursor under the stage will give you the reasons claims can go back to previous. What Exactly is PENDING DECISION APPROVAL? What happens after I submitted a revised version ... - JMIR Publications It may be that a review report is deemed unsuitable or that the paper is directly rejected, in which case the authors may have started to respond to a report unnecessarily. PENDING | Meaning & Definition for UK English | Lexico.com One reviewer thinks the article is a good fit for the journal; the other does not. Step 7. Report: Pending : The author is being contacted about the Editor-in-Chief's decision. How to Write an Interview Email Asking for the Decision It is likely that the change "under review" -> "decision pending" means that referee (s) report (s) were received, and now the editor has to make the decision. Average duration of "Pending Decision"? - ResearchGate